Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

An OOC part of the forum. IC posts will be deleted.
Post Reply
Rufus
Posts: 174
Joined: Mon Jun 26, 2023 12:33 pm

Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Rufus »

The deity Puckohue contentedly surveyed his realm. However, he spied one character, Rufus about to make supplications. Stack of scrolls were with him. How many supplications was he about to make?! Serious action would need to be taken! Divine thunderbolt/automatic death roll of a 12 was the minimum he should inflict.

Rules clarifications
1. Witnesses affect the chances that a conviction occurs. Do the rules for witnesses apply for those speaking on behalf of the accused as well as those speaking on behalf of the prosecution (i.e. can witnesses reduce the chance of successful prosecution)?
2. Does owning a property reduce other living expenses (don’t have to pay rent – but have upkeep costs instead)? Do Runelords and above (whose cult supplies accommodation) have to pay (some?) living expenses (food, clothing entertainment etc)?
3. Influence – if you have a favour valued at 3 and another valued at 2 and you wish to combine them, then do you get a favour worth 4 or does it remain at 3?
4. Are we playing with the following rule – taken from duel causes in the spontaneous duels section - “If a noble meets a non-noble who’s CHA is 4+ higher than theirs.” Fortunately Rufus is within 3 of Quatlu but it may not always have been the case.
5. After reading the background briefing, is Mularik’s company a cavalry as well as a magical regiment?
6. Do warchiefs and above benefit from regimental bonuses for battle outcomes? Related to the same question: if you are a warchief but lose regimental associations and you do not have command of a brigade; then does that mean you don’t go on campaign (except as a volunteer)?

Rules suggestions
Given the following rules:-
1. “Assistant Priests and above cannot belong to a regiment, unless in a Warrior Cult.”
It seems that those role playing a rise in a non warrior cult will struggle to advance socially as being in a regiment is a significant source of CPs and serving at the front can be a source of funding.
As a suggestion – an assistant priest or above in a trade cult (and therefore not in a regiment) could gain extra CPs for being wealthy or by trading. It is true that they are unlikely to face death rolls (unless duelling) but gives characters another way to progress. There could be similar rules for other types of cults (Chalona Arroy can serve as a regimental healer). Plus, of course, cult missions are a way to gain some benefits.
2. “Assistant Priests and above who are in a regiment use their Power instead of Battle to determine battle results.”
This rule may seem a bit harsh for those with a high battle rating but lower power. Should it be an option (whichever is higher or something else)?
3. Cult missions look pretty challenging (in other words downright dangerous) compared to fighting at the front. Would you consider allowing cult rank to affect outcomes. Also cults could affect outcomes – healer cult -1 on death rolls, trade cult +1 on loot etc.
4. Attending court seems a bit unattractive as it costs a week’s activity, 20 lunars and usually you get only one CP. Perhaps the following could be used? 2d6 to see who you can toady to. On 2-6 you cannot toady to anyone making this option to gain CPs to be unreliable.

Title..............Name....................Roll
King/Queen.....Argrath/Inkarne ........12
The Trickster... Elusu.....................11
The Lover ......Tarkala...................10
The Warlock....Mularik....................9
The Sage........Tosti Runefriend .........8
The Treasurer...Goldgotti..................7

5. In the original game, all characters were male, all potential lovers female and relationships were heterosexual. Not surprisingly, this has changed – which gives rise to the possibility of relationships between PCs. I think this would lead to madness! So suggest that we agree it is not possible. 😊

Thanks Puckohue for running the game :D
Baron Rufus Bronzer
Clansman of the proud Kheldon Tribe -This small but very wealthy urban clan is the "most noble" clan of Sartar - but the wealth seems to have passed me by.
Warlord Mularik's Company Orlanth Initiate
Chieftain's son.
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Rufus wrote: Wed Jan 03, 2024 11:07 am After reading the background briefing, is Mularik’s company a cavalry as well as a magical regiment?
No, it's not. Let's say they dismount before battle.

Tbh, I just tried to shoehorn some Sartarite regiments into the format set by the original EG! rules. Adding magical regiments was enough change.
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Rufus wrote: Wed Jan 03, 2024 11:07 am Do warchiefs and above benefit from regimental bonuses for battle outcomes? Related to the same question: if you are a warchief but lose regimental associations and you do not have command of a brigade; then does that mean you don’t go on campaign (except as a volunteer)?
Players of the original EG! game will notice that I've skipped the part about brevet ranks in the rules. Partly to protect my sanity.

When promoted to Warchief you will lose your regimental membership and stop using the regimental modifiers.

Officers without a command do not go on campaigns.

Unless you have a command to volunteer you'd have to volunteer as a Warrior in a tribal levy.
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Rufus wrote: Wed Jan 03, 2024 11:07 am an assistant priest or above in a trade cult (and therefore not in a regiment) could gain extra CPs for being wealthy or by trading.
...
cult missions are a way to gain some benefits.
Cult missions are comparable to going on campaign.

There are several ways money can buy you CPs. I don't see a reason to give CPs for simply having cash.

There a two additional things in the pipeline: Guild Appointments, and Trade Missions.
Fionn
Posts: 186
Joined: Tue Apr 25, 2023 9:21 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Fionn »

Puckohue wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 12:25 am
When promoted to Warchief you will lose your regimental membership and stop using the regimental modifiers.
Does this mean that such a character can become an Assistant Priest ("Assistant Priests and above can not belong to a regiment") and no longer needs to belong to a Warrior Cult?
Fionn the dagger, soldier and scholar (Warlord and Loremaster).
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Fionn wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 11:00 am
Puckohue wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 12:25 am
When promoted to Warchief you will lose your regimental membership and stop using the regimental modifiers.
Does this mean that such a character can become an Assistant Priest ("Assistant Priests and above can not belong to a regiment") and no longer needs to belong to a Warrior Cult?
Yes, it does, but I will add that they can not hold military appointments unless being a member of a Warrior cult to that rule.
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Rufus wrote: Wed Jan 03, 2024 11:07 am “Assistant Priests and above who are in a regiment use their Power instead of Battle to determine battle results.”
This rule may seem a bit harsh for those with a high battle rating but lower power. Should it be an option (whichever is higher or something else)?
Yes, it seems reasonable that if you are in a Warrior cult you could use your Battle skill if it's higher.

However, cult officials in other cults are supposed to primarily support the troops with their magic.
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Rufus wrote: Wed Jan 03, 2024 11:07 am Attending court seems a bit unattractive as it costs a week’s activity, 20 lunars and usually you get only one CP.
Yes, you'd need to get Royal Notice to get to toady.

However, at the Royal Feasts you can toady to the host.

The seasonal feasts (like the one in week 2 of 1631-3) will have special rules TBA.
Fionn
Posts: 186
Joined: Tue Apr 25, 2023 9:21 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Fionn »

Puckohue wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 11:10 am
Yes, it does, but I will add that they can not hold military appointments unless being a member of a Warrior cult to that rule.
You might want to be careful with that; there are a couple of regiments that follow Lhankor Mhy rather than a Warrior Cult, and it would be perverse to say that a Thane there has to join a new cult to become Adjutant (a job that requires tactics rather than bravery).

It would also be odd for a character who successfully rises through the ranks by Lhankor Mhy's strategy, cunning and magic to find that the army requires Generals to show personal prowess instead, but I suppose that is a decision for King Argrath rather than the GM :lol:
Fionn the dagger, soldier and scholar (Warlord and Loremaster).
Puckohue
GM
Posts: 2627
Joined: Thu Feb 09, 2023 7:17 pm

Re: Convictions, Costs, Cults, Court etc

Post by Puckohue »

Fionn wrote: Thu Jan 04, 2024 6:58 pm You might want to be careful with that; there are a couple of regiments that follow Lhankor Mhy rather than a Warrior Cult, and it would be perverse to say that a Thane there has to join a new cult to become Adjutant (a job that requires tactics rather than bravery).
They don't have to join a new cult, but they can't be an Assistant Priest or higher.
Post Reply